Interviews no image

Published on December 5th, 1999 | by Gerry Galipault


No sophomore slump for Tonic

After years struggling to make a name for itself, Tonic finally struck gold – and platinum – with its debut Polydor album, “Lemon Parade,” in 1997, along with a pair of indelible rock hits, “If You Could Only See” and “Open Up Your Eyes.”

Don’t think for a second that singer-guitarist Emerson Hart, guitarist Jeff Russo and bassist Dan Lavery weren’t worried about how to sustain that momentum.

All their fears were erased with the Nov. 9 release of “Sugar,” which debuted several weeks ago at No. 81 on the Billboard 200 pop chart, while the single “Knock Down Walls” climbs the mainstream rock track chart.

“That was always in the back of our minds, having a slump,” Hart said recently, “but we really as a band tried to make a conscious decision to leave that shit at the door. We had a record to make, we love the songs, and we knew they needed tender loving care and they needed to be put down on tape organically. We didn’t want to overproduce this record.”

They buckled down because they had to: They chose to produce “Sugar” themselves.

“It scared the hell out of the label,” Hart said, “but it was a great opportunity for us. We went from one label to another, and we said, ‘We want to produce our own record,’ and they were like, ‘Excuse me?’ We know the music the best; Jack Joseph Puig, who produced our first record, his schedule was all messed up. We said, ‘We can do this. We have the studio experience, we have the knowledge of the gear.’ We brought in a great engineer (Andy Wallace), who is a friend of ours. He drove the boat while we navigated the waters.

“The only part about it that sucked was the paperwork, staying on budget, the stuff that has nothing to do with the music. That’s kind of a drag. But we got through it. We had a great production assistant, she kind of took that weight. Once we had the freedom to have play time, we were okay.”

Tonic did itself proud: “Sugar” displays the band’s progressively improving songwriting, instrumentation and vocals – from the catchy opener “Future Says Run” to the instantly sweet “Waiting For the Light to Change.”

No one-hit-album wonder here.

“We’ve always been a slow burn, slow build kind of band, and that’s always worked in our favor,” Hart said. “We’ve had some great success right off the bat with this album; people have been really receptive to the songs. I don’t have any complaints.

“I chose this business for a reason, because this is what I love to do, this is all I know how to do. That’s why I was put here, to make music, whether it’s 10 people who understand it or 10 million. The only difference between 10 people and 10 million is a lifestyle, for me, and I can adapt to anything.”

Tonic is enjoying its ride, Hart says, and though the success of “Sugar” and the band’s recent tour with the Goo Goo Dolls will only enhance their popularity, they are prepared for the future, when it all inevitably subsides.

“As a band, we’re pretty frugal,” Hart said. “We don’t spend money where it’s unnecessary. We don’t do the planes and the jets and none of us has any bad drug habits. We’re just really careful where we put our money. I keep my money in the bank and set up my retirement fund and all that shit I don’t like to think about. But that’s the reality, it’s a hello-goodbye business. You never know when it’ll end, so you have to stay on top of your toes.

“When I started this, it wasn’t for the money, obviously, because I had so many years of no money. I’m in it because I love to play. The favorite part of my day is when I have my first coffee and cigarette and pick up my guitar. When that changes, I know I have to get out.”

BWF (before we forget): Toast Tonic on the Web @

Tags: ,

About the Author

Gerry Galipault debuted Pause & Play online in October 1997. Since then, it has become the definitive place for CD-release dates — with a worldwide audience.

Comments are closed.

Back to Top ↑


    Entertainment Weekly names Pause & Play one of “the 100 greatest Web sites”

  • Album Release Dates

    * Release dates are subject to change due to the ongoing impact of the COVID-19 pandemic

    Sept. 17, 2021 » Lil Nas X, Lindsey Buckingham, Melissa Etheridge, The Felice Brothers, Herb Alpert, Billy Idol, José González, Scotty McCreery, Jonas Kaufmann, Carly Pearce, Candlebox, Daughtry, Rumer, Carcass, Charley Crockett, etc.

    Sept. 24, 2021 » Mickey Guyton, Steely Dan, Ringo Starr, G-Eazy, Esperanza Spalding, Angels & Airwaves, Natalie Imbruglia, Donald Fagen, Japanese Breakfast, Sufjan Stevens & Angelo De Augustine, Alessia Cara, Vangelis, Anthony Hamilton, X Ambassadors, Billy Strings, Men Without Hats, Jesse Malin, Poppy, etc.

    Oct. 1, 2021 » Metallica, Tony Bennett & Lady Gaga, Brandi Carlile, The Doobie Brothers, Yes, the The, Ministry, Strand of Oaks, Roger Taylor, Newsboys, Asleep at the Wheel, Dar Williams, etc.

    More New Releases » Oct. 8 and Beyond: James Arthur, Ladyhawke, Sam Fender, Billy Bragg, Natalie Hemby, Old Dominion, Coldplay, Santana, Zac Brown Band, FINNEAS, Elton John, Lana Del Rey, Lady A, Duran Duran, Bullet For My Valentine, My Morning Jacket, Dream Theater, Ed Sheeran, Mastodon, Migos, Black Veil Brides, They Might Be Giants, ABBA, Diana Ross, Steve Perry, Hanson, Aimee Mann, Nathaniel Rateliff & The Night Sweats, Rod Stewart, Courtney Barnett, Eric Clapton, Damon Albarn, Allen Stone, Taylor Swift, Robert Plant | Alison Krauss, Sting, Jason Isbell and the 400 Unit, Paul Weller, Underoath, and many more.

    More Upcoming Releases » Albums coming in 2021 and 2022 but yet to be scheduled

    Elton John loves Pauseandplay.comDeals of the DayBest SellersSennheiser MOMENTUM 2 Wireless Over-Ear HeadphonesIE 400 Pro In-Ear Monitors

  • New Merch at Hot TopicSave on Tablets at Walmart.comBand T-ShirtsTurntables & AccessoriesHome Audio SystemsAmazon Tap $40 OffSave up to 90% on Textbooks

    NOTE: is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites. We also participate in other affiliate programs.

  • Love We do, too … Help us keep it going. (Every little bit helps.) We ♥ u.

  • Recent Posts

  • Connect on Facebook

  • On Twitter